Accountability in Relationships

The Apology That Isn't

A stick figure with arms crossed says 'I am sorry you feel that way.' A label beneath reads 'Translation: Your feelings are the problem, not my behavior.' The other figure looks deflated.
'I am sorry you feel that way.' Translation: your feelings are the problem, not what I did.
A stick figure says 'I am sorry, BUT you also...' A giant 'BUT' eraser wipes away the word 'sorry' in mid-air. The apology evaporates before landing.
Everything before the 'but' was a setup. Everything after it is what they actually believe.
A stick figure throws their hands up saying 'I ALREADY said sorry! What more do you want?' The word 'sorry' is being used as a weapon, swung at the other person. The other person flinches.
When 'sorry' becomes a weapon to end the conversation, it was never an apology. It was a shutdown.
A stick figure sitting calmly says 'I did that. It was wrong. I see how it hurt you. Here is what I am going to do differently.' No shields, no buts, no redirects. The other figure exhales.
A real apology does not defend, redirect, or expire. It lands because it has no escape hatch.

A tour through the most common fake apologies -- the deflection, the excuse, the weaponized sorry -- before arriving at what a real apology actually sounds like.

Explanation

Non-apologies are one of the most corrosive patterns in relationships because they wear the disguise of accountability while doing the opposite. 'I am sorry you feel that way' puts the problem on the hurt person's emotional response. 'I am sorry, but...' immediately negates the apology with a justification. 'I already said sorry, what more do you want?' weaponizes the apology itself, turning it into a tool to shut the conversation down. Harriet Lerner, author of 'Why Won't You Apologize?', identifies nine elements of a genuine apology, but the core is simple: acknowledge specifically what you did, validate the impact without caveat, and state what you will do differently. The hardest part is resisting the urge to explain, defend, or equalize. A real apology has no 'but.'

Key Takeaway

A real apology has no 'but,' no redirect, and no expiration date. It sounds like: 'I did this. It hurt you. Here is what I will change.'

Related Cartoons